Attacks on Homeless Excluded from Crime Data: Advocates

by T.J. Johnston, Newsdesk.org

• Sidebar: "Homelessness, by the Numbers?"
• Sidebar: "Human Faces, Lost in the Statistics"

Ricky Green of Bolinas, Calif., and Anthony Waters of Cleveland, Ohio, don't know each other, but they have this much in common: both are homeless and both were brutalized by packs of teenagers in June.

But their outcomes differed. Green survived. Waters did not. Advocates for the homeless say such violent acts by youth are on the rise, and should be considered hate crimes because the victims were homeless.

Whether the violence is part of a trend, however, is in dispute, in part because no one can agree on how to measure it.

Firsthand Narratives

"We have seen an increasing number of attacks on homeless people and the perpetrators have overwhelmingly been teenagers and young adults," said Michael Stoops, director of the National Coalition for the Homeless.

In April, NCH issued their annual report "Hate, Violence and Death on Main Street, USA," in collaboration with the National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty.

Compiling accounts from press reports, advocacy organizations and firsthand narratives from current and formerly homeless people, NCH documented 160 attacks on homeless people in 2007 resulting in 28 fatalities. The year before, 142 attacks and 20 deaths were recorded.

According to the NCH data, the assailants were predominantly male, and 86 percent of those accused and convicted were 25 years old or younger. Almost two-thirds were between 13 and 19.

Stoops said he believes the victims' status as homeless people motivate these attacks; while some attacks might be spontaneous, others are premeditated.

His organization also criticizes laws against panhandling and public sleeping as encouraging public animosity against the homeless.

"At city council meetings, people are saying bad things against homeless people," he said. "The general population hears this and a minority of them get the idea there's broad based support for cracking down on the homeless population," which can provoke physical violence as well.

"Some acts of violence are, for sure, hate crimes where teenagers and young adults sit around the kitchen table and plan an attack on the local homeless person," he adds. The refrain from the attackers, NCH found in most cases, was the acts were done for thrill seeking or "because they simply 'can.'"

But criminal justice experts dispute NCH's findings -- or at least how they arrived at them.

Michael Males, a senior researcher for the Center of Juvenile and Criminal Justice in San Francisco, said the numbers are too small to reflect a trend.

"There is no evidence of an 'epidemic' of teenage attacks on the homeless, let alone a rising one," he said, noting that the NCH study only counted attacks perpetrated by individuals with housing.

Furthermore, Males said if homeless people suffer assaults at the national average of 20.7 per 1,000 people annually, the number of attacks would hover around 15,000.

Dan Macallair, CJCJ's executive director, added that youth crime overall has been on the decline since 1994, citing FBI estimates.

State and Federal Laws

Stoops stand by NCH's numbers. He compares NCH's data collection methods to what gay rights and other minority groups have done to document hate crimes before laws against such crimes took effect in the 1990s.

"While it's easy to criticize our study, nobody else has done a damn thing -- no government agency, no legislative body," he said.

At the federal level, advocates are backing legislation by Rep. Eddie Bernice Johnson (D-Tex.) to amend existing hate crime laws to include homeless people.

The two bills authored by Johnson, H.R. 2216 and H.R. 2217, would include homeless status as criteria for tracking and sentencing of hate crimes.

"Until we get a federal law, we're trying to document the problem and come [up] with a way to get better data," Stoops said.

Meanwhile, on the state and local levels, new laws are gaining traction.

Since 2004, California has required law-enforcement officers to undergo training on hate crimes against homeless people, especially those with disabilities.

The following year, Maine passed a law that allows judges to consider a victim's homeless status when sentencing convicted offenders.

Legislatures in Massachusetts, Ohio and Alaska are also considering amending their hate crimes statutes to include homeless people.

In 2007, Seattle, Wash. became the first U.S. city to pass its own hate crimes law.

Instructional Video

Public schools in Miami, Fla. would like to prevent such crimes from ever happening. In response to the growing number of attacks on homeless people, the school district created a curriculum to humanize homeless people, especially their fellow classmates.

The curriculum's centerpiece is an instructional video, "It Could Happen To You," co-produced by NCH, Community Housing Partnership and the Miami-Dade Homeless Trust, and it will be distributed nationwide.

The video describes how people can become homeless and urges students to intervene if they see a homeless person get harassed.

A voiceover intones that homeless people have the same aspirations and rights as those with housing, and features NBA star Alonzo Mourning making a plea for empathy

17-year-old Diana represents the growing population of families who became homeless. In her case, Diana's parents lost their jobs, then their house.

"(Homeless people) are human beings, just like everybody else," she says in the video.

In Florida, the leading state in reported attacks on the homeless -- 31 last year, according to NCH statistics -- there's some urgency to her message.

The problem there is so acute that CBS News went to Florida to shoot a report broadcast on Sept. 21, 2008, report on attacks on homeless people.

John D'Amico of Daytona Beach is one such victim. He was struck on the head with a cinder block, leaving him visually impaired and the victim of last year's youngest assailants.

"I'm sure to a 10-year-old's mind, somehow it was my fault," D'Amico told CBS.

Some attackers are caught on tape with the perpetrators themselves posting the footage online. A You Tube search yields 1,500 videos under the title "bum fight."

But Ron Book, director of Miami-Dade Homeless Trust, hopes the educational video "It Could Happen To You" would teach students empathy.

"The only way to break the cycle is to get in and sensitize the people," Book said.

6 thoughts on “Attacks on Homeless Excluded from Crime Data: Advocates

  1. People without a home in North America is a tragdey. Then again I think of the rest of the 3/4 of the planet. Violence of young men is everywhere. We as a species have a small percentage of males that are just killers. Most countries put them into the army or help them in another way to utulize their aggression to a better means. Making more and more and more laws to legislate behaviour is stupid and only gives useless government officials a job instead of actually doing something to stop it. Some children are just born with something wrong with them. Let’s catch them early and do something then. Making laws just makes criminals of us all. Most homeless people have mental problems the rest are uneducated. Let us fix that problem first.

  2. Human Faces, Lost in the Statistics

    By T.J. Johnston, Newsdesk.org Main article: “Attacks on Homeless Excluded from Crime Data: Advocates” Since 1999, when the National Coalition…

  3. Great story, Mr Johnston! Ann: Actually, most homeless people *do not* have mental health problems. Most homeless people are poor & do not have the same kinds of safety nets that most middle class people have. You’re right that the solution isn’t legislation or the expansion of government bureaucracies, tho: It’s creating enough affordable housing, & improving both school & public education.

  4. While I appreciate any attempt to understand the causes of violence, I don’t necessarily applaud using Ricky Green as the poster boy for homelessness and implying that he and Anthony Waters of Cleveland necessarily had ANYTHING in common. Now, I admit I don’t know ANYTHING about Anthony Waters, but I suspect that Ricky Green may have aroused all sorts of feelings in his attackers. For one thing, Ricky is a physically beautiful young man who composed and sang music locally, where he had a number of fans. He dresses flamboyantly and was in such extraordinary physical condition when I met him that he could walk on his hands. In short, Ricky is, or was ( I haven’t seen him since his attack) a free-spirited, gifted, androgenous, outspoken beauty and he is African American. Bolinas has plenty of alternative lifestyle-loving people and there is no place better for someone like Ricky to find his place among them. Bolinas has always been a bohemian’s paradise. And, by the way, not all of his attackers were “residents” of Bolinas. The point is that Ricky was unlikely to have been attacked because he was “homeless.” It’s self-serving for homeless advocacy groups to adopt Ricky as their poster boy without offering a shred of evidence that his so-called homelessness had anything whatsoever to do with his attack. By using him, his name, and his case in this manner, reporters and homeless advocates are erasing the real person just as effectively as a pack of muggers might. I’ve followed the story since the day after it happened and to date, I’ve never seen anyone bother to cite the evidence or testimony in his case, except Gary Klien of the Marin Independent Journal who wrote, “According to court documents, the suspects told investigators that Green confronted them to seek retribution for a previous fight involving Manetta, another man and a friend of Green’s.. ” While there was obviously hatred involved, it’s not clear to me that Ricky’s “homelessness” had anything to do with it.

  5. The Top Overlooked News Stories of 2008

    Let’s take a look back at the remarkable stories NYMHM brought you in 2008, but that mass media missed. We…

  6. Homeless Gain Further Hate Crime Protections

    Homeless people are gradually being included in hate crimes laws, as the number of fatal attacks on the homeless remains…